I want to provide you with a puzzle to solve. It is called the nine-dot puzzle. Here’s how it works:
You will see an arrangement of nine dots below. To solve the puzzle you must connect all nine dots by making four straight lines. You cannot lift your pencil off the paper (or screen) while doing this, nor can you re-trace over your path.

Many of you may have already seen or solved this puzzle in the past. If so, that’s fine. If you haven’t, see if you can complete the puzzle given the instructions above. Don’t get stressed and don’t place any labels such as ‘hard’ or ‘easy’ on this puzzle. Just try doing it.
I’ll admit that I actually had quite a difficult time doing this and it took me awhile to complete. I finally had an ‘aha’ moment and was able to complete it, but we’ll talk more about that in a minute. You’ll find the solution here (note: when you get to the page, click on the link ‘see solution.’)
What the Puzzle Shows Us
I, like most people, immediately looked at this puzzle in the construct of a box. When looking at nine dots laid out this way, our mind immediately tries to categorize and label what we’re seeing. For most, an image of a box, or square comes to mind. It’s from that perspective that I began this puzzle and started connecting the dots in the confines of the box. This inevitably led to confusion and frustration because I was not able to connect all dots without drawing more than four lines.
My ‘a ha’ moment came when I got frustrated and thought ‘c’mon, think outside the box here…what’s the solution?’ It was in that moment that my whole perspective and way of looking at the puzzle changed. I started to draw lines extending out of the imaginary boundary I had placed around the dots and was able to solve the puzzle a few minutes later. Ironically, I think the term ‘think outside the box’ might come from this puzzle. Let’s just say I have a whole new appreciation for that phrase, which I once thought was lame business jargon.
The puzzle itself is not confined to the boundary around the nine dots (i.e. the box). In order to solve the puzzle you have to change your perspective and see that the whole piece of paper/screen/surface is the field for solving the puzzle. If you confine yourself to the box itself you will likely get frustrated, down on yourself or think that it’s impossible to solve. I’ll admit that some of these feelings came over me as I worked through this.
Often in life, we fall into confined thinking patterns that can be detrimental to ourselves. As an example, maybe you have a desire to do something different than what you’re doing right now. Let’s be more specific and relate it to your job. Maybe you’re not happy with what you’re doing, but your current thinking patterns are not allowing you to move beyond the ‘problem’ of not liking your job. You may say things to yourself such as ‘I don’t know what I want to do,’ ‘I can’t leave this job,’ or ‘I will never be successful if I try to start my own business.’ When you do this you are essentially confining yourself to a set way of doing things. You will never be able to move beyond the problem or reach a satisfactory solution, much like the puzzle above, because you have confined yourself to habitual and limited ways of thinking.
If you have thought patterns such as above, maybe it’s time to start looking at things with a fresh perspective. You are more than the sum of your thoughts. There is a wholeness and connectedness that you can tap into when you start looking beyond your thoughts and trying new things. Continuing on the example above, maybe you want to start your own business but you don’t know how or don’t know where to start. Are you in a perpetual state of looking for the answers or hoping someone else will give you the answers? Do you just read blog posts, but don’t take any action?
Start moving beyond your fears and doubts and just try . It’s as simple and as powerful as that. See what happens and experiment. Like the nine dot puzzle above, you might have an ‘a ha’ moment and realize that you are not limited in what you can do. You’ll find that what you might have thought was too difficult or impossible is in fact not so difficult at all once you begin to see and connect to your wholeness.
A human being is part of a whole, called by us the Universe, a part limited in time and space. He experiences himself, his thoughts and feelings, as something separated from the rest a kind of optical delusion of his consciousness. This delusion is a kind of prison for us, restricting us to our personal desires and to affection for a few persons nearest us. Our task must be to free ourselves from this prison by widening our circles of compassion to embrace all living creatures and the whole of nature in its beauty. – Albert Einstein
I’m Nate, a writer, mindfulness practitioner and student of the inner workings of the mind.



I remember seeing this puzzle a few years ago and it took me a while to solve. Solutions to problems really do often become so obvious and clear once we break through those boundaries of thought. But it just goes to show how well our brains are conditioned ..and how much effort it takes to un-train ourselves so that we are no longer confined by such narrow thinking.
Trying new things and putting yourself out of your comfort zone, where you are forced to think wildly and outside the box, is perhaps the best way to do so. That’s great advice you offer, advice that we all should repeat upon waking up every morning!
.-= Earl´s last blog ..Unexpected Encounters With Intriguing People =-.
Hi Earl!
Yes, I think you’re right. It also is something to look back on whenever we feel stuck in a particular thought or opinion (e.g. “I can’t do this,” or “I’m right, you’re wrong”). When we notice ourselves falling into these confined ways of thinking, it’s helpful to look back at this puzzle and then re-look at the problem to see if we’re really seeing the problem as a whole.
Haha, think outside of the box… damn, I didn’t get it. My patience for these games is waaaay to small! But I really like the lesson this shows. So thanks for that!
.-= Fabian | The Friendly Anarchist´s last blog ..Enter “Do Mode” (The Only Productivity Secret You’ll Ever Need) =-.
Yeah…it was kind of crazy Fabian. I was getting so frustrated and that phrase came into my mind exactly because I was picturing the problem as a ‘box.’ It was then that the light bulb when off and I was able to see the dots as a subset of the entire page. That’s when I started drawing lines that went out of the imaginary boundary I had placed around the dots.
Going back to what I mentioned to Earl above, it’s helpful to think of this puzzle whenever we feel ‘trapped’ in a problem or feel there isn’t a solution. Also, I think it’s helpful to think of this puzzle when we find ourselves completely entrapped in certain opinions.
Yes, we tend to limit ourselves to ‘either or’ thinking when reality is more about ‘yes and’. The solution to many problems often appears from left field, a place outside of rational mind. I am curious to see where this ah ah experience is going to lead you!
.-= Marguerite Manteau-Rao´s last blog ..Under The Trees With Buddha =-.
Marguerite -
Thanks for stopping by! I too am very curious to see where this takes me
In the short-term it is making me more open minded. If I see or feel myself having some sort of limited belief, I start to question and look at it more now. I’m trying to look at things from a perspective of wholeness now.
Hi Nate, I’ve just stopped by for the first time, and saw this post – I love this puzzle! I’ve used it a few times to illustrate (literally) the benefits of “thinking outside the box”. It’s amazing how people have an “aha” moment right in front of your eyes – “so THAT’s what it means to think outside the box, I never knew…”. I also love that there’s more than one solution to this problem, which shows that there’s also more than one way of thinking outside the box…and when you realise that, it’s so exciting to see what follows!
Thanks, Topi
Yes! For me, it was this sudden realization of how we can get trapped in our thoughts….or that, things aren’t always as they appear to be. I literally thought there wasn’t a solution and I got very frustrated when first trying to solve this…that’s when you start to notice the thoughts popping into your head, such as ‘there is no solution, ‘I can’t do this,’ etc. The same ol’ stories we create around other problems in our life. The truth is, if we’re willing to open up a bit (even if we think we don’t know the answer right away or think there isn’t a solution) we might find that the ‘answer’ suddenly jumps out at us.